May 3, 2008

From the land of 5 cent oranges and 50 dollar fertilizer

Every time I turn on the radio, seems like I hear one more thing about the international crisis of rising food prices. It's happening here too, prices for cooking oil, rice, corn, potatoes and other staples have gone way, way up. And I'm not entirely pleased with the explanations, which are mostly just that we're making too much ethanol and China is eating too much meat (grain-fed, presumably).

Both of these are likely true, but the US deciding to turn corn into ethanol is not as simple as economic supply and demand changing. The United States has been selling corn below its cost to grow it for years. Now it looks like instead of dumping below-cost corn, we'll use it to drive our cars. So now not only is supply lowered, a source of market distortion that was forcing prices down is gone too.

And it's overly simplistic to suggest, as I've heard, that only now are crop prices tied to oil prices because of ethanol. Crop prices in a world without massive below-cost dumping will be tied to oil prices as long as farmers use chemical inputs, nearly all of which are made from petroleum products. Of course corn prices will be high: The di-ammonium phosphate fertilizer everyone puts on their corn and wheat here recently went from $28 in October to $50 last I heard. For 50 kg. A farmer will put about 4 of those 50 kg sacks on a hectare of field. Plus herbicides, pesticides, Urea (ammonium nitrate, up to $30 from $15 a year ago). In places where tractors are more common, and combines, and all other gas-powered implements, add in the cost of gasoline. The price of agricultural commodities has been tied to the price of oil since probably 1950, and it doesn't look like it'll change anytime soon.